Platform “Komentari” brings together professionals that offer the public a critical view of the events taking place in Georgia and the World.

Why isn’t the voice of ethnic minorities heard at the local level?

The governance models established under liberal democracies have weakened the political role of citizens and bestowed disproportionate power upon the elite. Over time, it became evident that the concept of political representation of the people fell short of its initial objectives. Growing dissatisfaction and protests posed threats to elite stability, compelling concessions of power. This led to the emergence of participatory democracy, a governance model emphasizing citizen involvement in decision-making processes. With time its mechanisms evolved too. However, states have thus far failed to ensure equal opportunities for participation for all societal groups, particularly ethnic minorities, hindering the consideration of their needs in policy-making and exacerbating societal inequalities. This challenge extends to Georgia as well.

Read More

Gambling, Social Welfare, and Role of a State

According to the World Health Organization, there has been a notable global surge in both, investment in and the consumption of gambling recently. In Georgia, gambling venues are notably abundant, particularly concentrated in tourist and coastal areas, fostering a rising dependence on gambling, accompanied by a heightened prevalence of associated social risks.

The increasing prevalence of gambling and, moreover, risks associated with it, highlight the necessity of examining the issue from a broader perspective. This extends the discourse to encompass discussion about the models of democracy, the concept of liberty, and public welfare.

Read More

The crisis of representative democracy in Georgia – Why doesn’t the government work for the people?

Representative democracy claims to operate for the people, exercising power under their authority and in their name. Originally conceived to rectify historical imbalances stemming from the societal dichotomy of “ruling” and “ruled” segments, this model entrusts power to an elected elite, chosen through the democratic process. The distinctive characteristic of the representative system lies in the fact that a singular element – the public interest – serves as the source of both its authority and legitimacy. The legitimacy of representative governance is established through the conscientious consideration of public interests, resulting in a freely made choice. Its legitimacy is upheld when it operates within these interests. However, contemporary scholarly literature frequently discusses the crisis within this model. This crisis, arising from multiple factors, is most distinctly manifested in two key areas – firstly, the crisis of voter representation (who is left outside the political processes and who is included within),  and secondly, the crisis of safeguarding the voter’s interests.

The crisis of representation is not only a problem of emerging states. However, it has different foundations and forms in fragile and stable democracies. We will examine this matter through the example of Georgia, concentrating specifically on safeguarding voters’ interests.

Read More

How do foreign influence bills exacerbate polarization?

In a bipartite political landscape, emotional polarization stands out as the most effective mechanism of voter mobilization. In such an environment, political parties often tend to forego the development of comprehensive strategies to address societal issues. Instead, politics becomes overshadowed by propaganda, as parties seek support through meaningless attacks on their opponents.

Read More

Crime, Dream, and Reality in the History of Georgia – Do we still have a chance to restore justice?

The democratic transformation of a state is never successful without a proper response to its repressive past. Contemporary observations of post-repressive states have unequivocally dispelled the notion that “historical amnesia” serves as a remedy for assuaging collective trauma and fostering a resilient democratic framework. Employing oblivion as a governance strategy proves inadequate in supplanting the public memory and constantly creates the risk of inciting conflicts and reinstating oppression.

Read More

The electoral threshold must be reduced

Democracy has never had the luxury of closing the door to those willing to participate in the governance of the state. Unfortunately, the political elite of Georgia has always acted to the contrary (with rare exceptions), when coming to a decision on this matter. 

Read More